Commentary « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change

By: Civil Society Coalition On Climate Change  06-Dec-2011
Keywords: Climate Change, Online Chat, Climate Scientist

A guest post by Todd Myers of the Washington Policy Center.

The story’s headline captures the tone: “Climate change takes toll on coffee growers, drinkers too”. The impact of climate change on coffee, they argue, has been significant. “Yields in Costa Rica have dropped dramatically in the last decade,” the Times wrote, “with farmers and scientists blaming climate change for a significant portion of the troubles.”

But there are factual problems with the story.

(1) According to NASA, Costa Rican temperatures during 2008-09, the years with the largest drop in production, were only 0.6 degrees warmer than the 20th century baseline. The most significant increase occurred in the fall (September-November, 2008), of just over 1 degree F. This was left out of the story.

(2) Average temperatures in 2008-09 were only 0.1 degrees warmer than 1998-2000, when Costa Rican
coffee harvests were 68 percent larger. The largest difference occurred in the fall, a difference of only 0.7 degrees.

(3) Temperatures in 2008-09 are actually 0.1 degrees lower than the average annual temperature during the 1991-93 period, which marked the country’s highest coffee production.

Even the climate scientist chosen by the Seattle Times to participate in an online chat about the story threw cold water on the link between the crop declines and climate change. Dr. Mike Wallace, a climate scientist at the University of Washington told me “the warming of the past 10 years is pretty small, both globally and over Costa Rica. I’m not at all sure that it’s been a factor in the decline of coffee production on this short time scale.”

Science journalism can be especially susceptible to the urge to substitute a simple, compelling story for the complexity of data-based science. Reporting the uncertainties of scientific information may not result in gripping journalism, but it is critical to enabling the public and policymakers to rely on the stories they read about climate change or the other environmental challenges we face.

Keywords: Climate Change, Climate Scientist, Online Chat,

Contact Civil Society Coalition On Climate Change

Email

Print this page

Other products and services from Civil Society Coalition On Climate Change

06-Dec-2011

Events « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change

Mao Shoulong, Executive Deputy Director of School of PublicPolicy, Renmin University of China. Conference Room 1, Yifu Conference Center, Renmin University of China. Hosted by School of Public Policy, Renmin University of China.


06-Dec-2011

Press Releases « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change - press releases

Some of the blame can be attributed to the recession, but rising energy costs caused by renewable portfolio standards certainly worsened the financial hardships faced by low-income Oregon residents. In 2007, Oregon legislators passed Senate Bill 838 which established a state Renewable Portfolio Standard, effectively forcing utility customers to purchase renewable energy.


06-Dec-2011

Reports « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change

In light of that and the large number of other international conferences that have been held this year, taxpayers around the world – who will be supporting the conference and the delegations being sent there – might question whether the conference will constitute good value for money.


06-Dec-2011

Uncategorized « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change

In the introduction to his book “The Green Wave” about the fundraising prowess of the environmental community, Bonner Cohen notes that as environmental groups become more powerful, they often forget their original goal of helping the environment. In his memoirs released last year, Blair expresses his frustration with non-governmental organizations , especially environmental groups.


06-Dec-2011

Press Releases « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change

The latest example is climate change, undermining “the full and effective enjoyment of human rights” by jeopardising food and health, the latest draft for the international summit in Copenhagen in December says. For activists it would indeed be a great coup to give their agenda a legal, human-rights, standing — and the prospect of cash is attractive to such backers as Bangladesh.


06-Dec-2011

Spanish « Civil Society Coalition on Climate Change

Las restricciones globales a los gases de invernadero perjudicarían la capacidad de personas en países subdesarrollados para enfrentarse a los problemas de hoy así como también a los del futuro al retrasar el crecimiento y el desarrollo económico. La Coalición está compuesta por 58 organizaciones independientes de la sociedad civil quienes comparten el interés de mejorar el conocimiento público sobre una variedad de temas de políticas públicas.